Ohio, United States
I Scream Gelato at Polaris offers a casual spot for scooping gelato, desserts, and hot beverages in Columbus, OH. Accessible with onsite, takeout, and delivery options.
4.7 / 5
Guest rating
318
Reviews
Ice Cream Shop
Cuisine
Ohio
City
Closes at 8:00 PM
I Scream Gelato - Polaris is a casual and trendy ice cream and dessert shop situated inside Polaris Mall in Columbus, Ohio. This location specializes in a variety of gelato flavors alongside classic and creative frozen treats, offering a quick sweet escape for visitors.
The menu features gelato served in cones or to go, beverages like hot chocolate and milkshakes, and desserts such as Belgian waffles and affogatos. With no table service, this spot is designed for fast visits, making it popular for solo diners and groups alike.
Open for onsite visits, takeout, and delivery, it accommodates various preferences and has wheelchair accessible entrances and parking. Payment methods accepted include credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
Signature dishes, shareable plates, and the items regulars keep coming back for.
Grouped by category — each group lists what's available and what isn't at I Scream Gelato - Polaris.
When I Scream Gelato - Polaris is open during the week.
Closes at 8:00 PM
Central Ohio, with cafes, shops, and other restaurants within easy walking distance.
A look at the food, the dining room, drinks, and the exterior of I Scream Gelato - Polaris.
What recent guests say after dining at I Scream Gelato - Polaris.
Based on 318 guest reviews
Kate Douglas
May 31, 2026"Went to the mall location today and passed by the display and had to stop for a treat. The price was very reasonable , the customer service was outstanding , and the gelato was perfect. I would highly recommend this place based on the service alone, but the gelato is outstanding. The pricing is also very reasonable i got a large with sprinkles for $7.95. Definitely come here!"
Markia M (Kiamill)
May 11, 2026"The pineapple(vegan) and strawberry (regular) gelatos were superb! The pineapple was so light and refreshing, with tiny fresh fruit chunks in it. The strawberry was fresh and creamy. The cute, personalized waffle wafer was a nice edible aesthetic."
Afrika Fown
Mar 25, 2026"Great service! The guy working today was so kind and made great conversation. 10/10 experience and the gelato was delicious!"
JoNo X
Mar 21, 2026"This is a pretty good gelato spot in Polaris mall. I Scream Gelato had a lot of good flavors to choose from compared to most gelato places. There was a richness to the flavor of the gelato and I enjoyed it overall. If you want a quick sweet treat and you are already in the mall, I would definitely stop by. Also the waffle chip that is included was a good touch."
Common questions about I Scream Gelato - Polaris to help plan a visit.
Guests can choose from gelato in various sizes, Belgian and bubble waffles, affogatos, and specialty beverages like hot chocolate and milkshakes.
The shop features wheelchair accessible entrances and parking to support accessible visits.
Yes, delivery, takeout, and onsite service options are available to accommodate different preferences.
There is no table service; the shop is designed for quick visits where customers order and pick up at the counter.
Payments can be made using credit cards, debit cards, or NFC mobile payment methods.
The environment is casual and kid-friendly with menu items that appeal to younger guests.
The atmosphere is casual and trendy, suited for both solo diners and groups seeking a quick sweet treat.
27 S Summer St, Edgartown, MA 02539, United States
Jl. Hikmah No.14, Pisangan, Kec. Ciputat Tim., Kota Tangerang Selatan, Banten 15419, Indonesia
Jl. Simpang Borobudur No.1A, Mojolangu, Kec. Lowokwaru, Kota Malang, Jawa Timur 65142, Indonesia
Keep your listing accurate by updating your address, opening hours, menu, photos, and contact details. Reach more diners searching for Ice Cream Shop in Ohio on Locallya.
